The Broken Ear
The Broken Ear (1937) is the story of a thrilling pursuit. Tintin sets off to South America to retrieve a stolen fetish. There, all sorts of interests are in conflict: military, economic and the war of the Gran Chaco which had been opposing Bolivia and Paraguay for the past three years. A small Arumbaya statue has been stolen in a museum, then returned. One little detail though will tell Tintin that instead of the original, a mere replica was returned. There must be a secret hiding behind this small statue since its robbery was carefully concealed. This is in South America that Tintin will find the key to this enigma.
Test your knowledge
Covers of The Broken Ear in French
The story behind the cover and endpapers
The sixth album of the series was released in 1937 with a "small picture" stuck on the cover and grey (or white) endpapers. It is undoubtedly the rarest and most sought-after version among collectors. Some have claimed that the first version of The Broken Ear was the version with blue endpapers, but this is not exact, the blue endpapers will appear in the second version, assembled at the beginning of 1938.
The Blue endpapers appeared in 1937 on the initiative of Charles Lesne. It is a double-page spread printed in dark blue on thick grey paper, with 34 illustrations in reserve. The Broken Ear should have benefited from the blue endpapers from the first print run simultaneously with the 1937 reprints of Tintin in the Congo and Tintin in America, but the first copies of The Broken Ear were assembled with grey endpapers. Hence their rarity!
© Hergé - Moulinsart 2021
The Arumbaya fetish
The plot of The Broken Ear revolves around the theft of a statue from a museum. Tintin is on the case, which will ultimately lead the little reporter deep into the heart of the Amazonian jungle. A story that begins with intrigue and simple detective work unexpectedly develops into a madcap and nail-biting adventure.
The pre-Columbian wooden statuette belonging to the collections of the Royal Museums of Art and History of Brussels
The mysterious and coveted Arumbaya fetish is in reality a small pre-Columbian statue that belongs to the Royal Museum of Art and History in Brussels. The origins of this statuette are far removed from the Amazon region: it comes from the area surrounding the city of Trujillo in North Peru. The real museum piece does not have a broken ear, while the only way of telling the "real" statue in the story, is precisely by its broken ear!
San Theodoros as symbolic of Latin American politics
The San Theodoros portrayed in The Broken Ear and Tintin and the Picaros, is first and foremost a symbol of the instability and violence that has gripped South American politics for so long, as well as a model of a poor city in the third world, ravaged by brutal power struggles masked as ideological conflicts. The Broken Ear plays out as a kind of "naïve documentary based on the Western perception of South America in the 1930s." (Philippe Goddin, Hergé et les Bigotudos, Casterman, p.15).
© Hergé - Moulinsart 2021
Hergé addresses the archetypal aspects of twentieth-century Latin America: revolutions, coups, arms dealing, smuggling and corrupt business.
Ironic comic or playful parable?
Hergé takes up the theme of the reports he read in Le Crapouillot magazine, which he turned to for information: dictators and puppet governments of banana republics, manipulated by international trade, arms dealers, and the military and industrial ambitions of world powers such as the United States and Great Britain. It is these big players that are behind the coups, revolutions and wars.
Bolivar and Olivaro
The name of the liberator of San Theodoros, General Olivaro (1805-1899), is a clear allusion to General Bolivar, liberator of the Spanish colonies to the north of South America, which formed what was called the Gran Colombia.
Sir Basil Zaharoff
Hergé thinly disguised the inspiration behind his character Mazaroff (in the black and white French version), who was renamed Bazaroff in the colour version. The real-life character was called Basil Zaharoff (1849-1936), and Hergé found out about Zaharoff in Le Crapouillot.
Photograph of Sir Basil Zaharoff in "Le Crapouillot"
Of Greek origin, Sir Basil Zaharoff showed remarkable acumen in business matters and made himself indispensable to the great powers to which he indiscriminately sold weapons. Zaharoff often stoked tensions by convincing clients that they were at risk from his other clients, and the most powerful arms dealer in the world was supported by politicians and financiers in many countries. In Le Crapouillot, he was quoted as being one of the most powerful people in the world./p>
The 'big hat' conflict
In another reference to real life, Hergé alludes to the Gran Chaco conflict (1928-1935) between Bolivia and Paraguay. The Gran Chaco region was split between the two countries. Hergé had already written about oil in Tintin in America and would return to the theme in Land of Black Gold.
In 1932, the skirmishes that had so far characterised the Gran Chaco conflict made way for official declarations of war between Bolivia to Paraguay. The war would finally come to an end in 1935. A treaty ratified on 21 July 1938 attributed the main region of the contested territories to Paraguay while conceding access to the Paraguay River, to Bolivia. Hergé loved wordplays and thinly disguised this real-life conflict under the name Gran Chapo (meaning 'big hat' in English): San Theodoros (capital city Las Dopicos) masquerades as Bolivia (capital city La Paz) while Nuevo Rico (capital city Sanfacion) plays Paraguay (capital city Asuncion).
A real aeroplane
The aircraft in which Alonso Perez and Ramon Bada travel to South America, is a Breguet Wibault-Penhoet 283 - a tri-engine Air France machine - that is easily distinguishable by its landing gear.
Case D3 on page 12 of The Broken Ear. © Hergé - Moulinsart 2021
Air France's Breguet Wibault-Penhoet 283
The road to death
The winding mountain road that Tintin drives down following his escape from General Alcazar's jail, exists in real life. It is La Yungas Road, the infamous Bolivian 'road of death', built during the 1930s by Paraguayan prisoners of war. Tintin's car careens over the edge of the mountain, although the little reporter manages to jump clear at the last moment.
Case C3 on page 39 of The Broken Ear. © Hergé - Moulinsart 2021
Yungas rd. © psamathe.net 2015-2020. All Rights Reserved.
Following in the footsteps of Percival Harrison Fawcett
Tintin's journey through this territory begins when he jumps from a bridge into the river making up the border between Bolivia and Paraguay. The little reporter then arrives at Don José Trujillo's hacienda, and later leaves by canoe in search of the Arumbayas.
© Hergé - Moulinsart 2021
In the issue of Le Petit Vingtième published on 5 November 1936, Don José explains to Tintin that: "The last man to try was a British explorer, Ridgewell. He went more than ten years ago. He's never been seen since." Hergé was inspired by famous real-life British explorer Lieutenant Colonel Percy Fawcett, whose last letter to his wife was dated 29 May 1925. Fawcett became Ridgewell, gaining skills in the use of a blowpipe while in the process of transformation.
Two rival tribes in the Amazon
In the heart of the Amazonian jungle, Tintin meets Ridgewell and the Arumbayas in the same place where British explorer Percy Fawcett disappeared in 1925! The Arumbayas, who speak disguised Brussels dialect, are similar to the real life Jivaro Indians, and have the Rumbaba tribe (who specialise in shrinking heads) as enemies. The Arumbayas live on the banks of the River Coliflor in San Theodoros.
© Hergé - Moulinsart 2021
For his research, Hergé turned to Travels in the Americas (1875) by A.J. Walker, the same book that Tintin consults while investigating the theft of the fetish.